Straights vs Mixes: What’s Best for Your Garden
Welcome back to The Puzzle Seed Co.! We’re here to help you navigate the world of wild bird feeding, starting with one of the most common questions: should you choose Straights (single ingredients) or Mixes(blended feeds)?
As a proud stockist of the expert Eyebrookrange, we’ve broken down the advantages of each to help you choose the best option for your garden and your feathered visitors.1. Defining Your Bird Food
The distinction is simple and helps you understand what you are feeding your local wildlife:
-
Straights (Single Seed Type)
- Definition: These are bird foods consisting of just one type of seed or ingredient, such as Black Sunflower Seeds, Niger Seed, or Peanut Granules.
- The Eyebrook View: Eyebrook offers a range of high-quality straights, guaranteeing the purity and freshness of a single food source.
-
Mixes (Multiple Seed Types)
- Definition: These are carefully formulated blends combining multiple seeds, nuts, and sometimes additives like suet or dried mealworms.
- The Eyebrook View: Eyebrook blends are designed to ensure a mix of ingredients is present to cater to different dietary needs and preferences all in one feeder.
2. The Advantages of Feeding Straights
Choosing a straight seed offers several key benefits, especially for a focused feeding strategy:
- Targeting Specific Birds: If you know you want to attract Goldfinches, a specific feeder with Niger Seed is unbeatable. If you want to cater to acrobatic Tits and Finches, Sunflower Hearts are perfect. Straights allow for precision.
- Easier Control: You know exactly what you are putting out. This makes it easier to monitor how much of a specific food is being eaten.
- Less Waste: Birds may ignore seeds they dislike in a mix, dropping them to the ground. With a straight, if you've chosen a favorite like Sunflower Hearts, you’ll likely see less being discarded.
3. The Advantages of General Mixes
Blended feeds are fantastic for a broader approach to wild-bird feeding:
- Broader Appeal: A quality mix is formulated to appeal to the widest variety of garden bird species—from ground-feeding Robins to feeder-loving Finches—all in one place. This means more activity and a more diverse range of birds visiting your garden.
- Better for Beginners: When you are just starting out, a good general-purpose mix is the easiest way to ensure you are providing a balanced diet and attracting a wide array of species before you commit to more specialized feeding.
- All-in-One Solution: A premium mix simplifies your feeding routine, ensuring all birds get some energy-rich food without needing multiple feeders for multiple seed types.
4. Which One Should You Pick?
Your choice depends on your experience and goals:
| Feeder Experience | Feeding Goal | Recommended Option | Why? |
|---|---|---|---|
| Beginner | Attract the widest variety of birds to start. | Mixes | Easy, effective, and guaranteed to be eaten by most species. |
| Intermediate/Advanced | Cater to specific species (e.g., attract more Goldfinches). | Straights | Allows for precise targeting and customization of your feeding station. |
| All Levels | Year-round feeding without hassle. | A combination of both | Use a quality mix as your base, and supplement with a straight (like Sunflower Hearts) in a separate feeder for the birds who crave a single, high-energy food. |
Ready to Find Your Perfect Match?
The best way to know what works is to test it out!
- Try one of each in a separate feeder and compare the results over a few weeks. Which one attracts the most activity?
- Browse our full stock of Eyebrook Straights and Mixes today and start building your perfect wild bird menu!